September 22 2025

The One That Got Away (and the Ones That Didn’t)

by Michael McMahon

It’s human nature—you think about that one that got away. It’s always going to be bigger than the one you landed. Photos and videos by Cal Wheaton

Perfect Conditions

Conditions were ideal Friday morning when we left Bass River at 6:30. Sunrise was spectacular as we were getting ready to board Captain Tyler’s 28’ Whitewater. Water was calm, air was cool with just a light breeze.

The day would eventually warm up into the low 70’s. Perfect. I’ve been on a handful of Tyler’s striper trips, but this would be my first going after Albies. Everything everyone ever told me was that they were finicky, you had to cast well, and you needed to track them down, which was no easy task. Given that, I was going in with low expectations and planned to enjoy the day out on the water.

A Great Crew

These trips provide an opportunity to meet up with some amazing folks all looking to get fish on board, and this group was one of the best. Cal @Calwheaton, Brendon @OuterCapefish, and @Stark134, along with myself, had varying levels of experience, and we were all looking to hunt down Albies. I have to give a shout-out to Cal, who took a ton of photos and videos which we’ve included here in this post.

Getting Started

Captain Tyler headed west out of the mouth of the Bass River, and things started a bit slow. Tracking down birds and surface activity, we were able to land a couple of blues.

So much of a trip’s success boils down to having a captain put you on the fish. Tyler has never failed in the past, and he would come up big again on Friday.

Click here to continue reading how this crew located and caught some of the largest albies we've seen on MFCC within the past two weeks.

About the author 

Michael McMahon

Mike has been a member of My Fishing Cape Cod since 2021. Last year during Black Friday, Mike made the leap and joined 19 other members by becoming a Lifetime Member of the site! Mike enjoys fishing for various species and has joined numerous MFCC group trips. It's great having you as part of the community Mike!


{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

You may also like

"The Monomoy season was consistent and action-packed," says Captain Tyler Putney of Flatliner Charters.There's no better striped bass fishery on the Cape,

Read More
Cracking the Code: What Worked (and Didn’t) at Monomoy in 2025

In today's podcast and blog post, longtime MFCC member Gretchen Stiers discusses her fishing journey, memorable catches, and the strong sense of

Read More
5 Years of Landing Fish and Making Friends: Gretchen Stiers’ MFCC Journey
>