December 12 2023

Fishing the Quiet Solitude of Late Autumn on Cape

by My Fishing Cape Cod member Calvin Toran-Sandlin
1 comments

*This report is part of our recently launched Offseason Challenges program. You can learn more about how the challenges work by clicking here.  

For this challenge, My Fishing Cape Cod member Calvin Toran-Sandlin recaps a successful freshwater fishing trip from December 10th, 2023. This report was first shared here inside our members' forum.

Fallen leaves and bare trees. The glassy surface of the pond chased down and disrupted by the building gusts of an incoming system. The Cape’s fresh water bodies have a silent, paused atmosphere to them as if the ponds themselves are settling in for the winter ahead.

Overhead a lone Blue Heron circles and glides, coming to rest on the opposing bank. Two anglers, by beak and by rod, creeping the gray edges in search of stirring life.

On these cold days, now far removed from the roiling bioluminescence of the summer surf, I’ll turn my attention to what the sweet water has to offer. This is lonely fishing, slow, and in a way somber.


Fishing the Quiet

On these trips I’ll occasionally break from the gray peace with a quiet audiobook for some simple company. The nature of woods and ponds seem to call of high fantasy. In this failing season of life and death the lines blur and the literature seems in a way to come of life.

There’s an excerpt from a Tolkien poem, a line that seems to touch the experience and the quarry “All that is gold does not glitter”. Lurking under the surface, against the mud and the dead reeds and grass of a past season, the living flashes of gold lose some of their luster as they take on their winter hue. Deep browns, and washed out silvers and yellows.

Yet for lack of glitter, the life and the camouflaged gold remains, tough and pugnacious, the trout and bass, perch and pickerel, remain hungry and watchful in their wintery holes.

I approach these waters with a quiet stealth, it takes little to spook these fish hanging along the drop offs or catching a fleeting sun in the shallows. With an incoming low pressure system and building winds I went out with the intention of spot hopping, targeting leeward lines and quiet shallow coves. Life over size, the intention simply to connect with hopefully hungry fish spurred to feed by the impending weather.

Trekking through the wooded edges of the pond I come to stop at the breaks and along exposed sections of shoreline to make a few casts before scouting onward.


Tackle & Gear

My gear is simple and light. A tiny spinning reel taped unceremoniously to an ultralight rod and complemented with a thin, quality 4 lb monofilament mainline.

In my pockets a couple of small boxes of likely offerings.

  • Small jerkbaits
  • Spoons
  • Metals
  • Ultralight plastics and tubes

The goal, to mimic the resident baits of the pond. Insect larvae and leeches, and the minnows that occasionally still dart in shallows.

My rotation is simple with a few consistent favorites, the classic shallow diving Rapala, the glinting Al’s goldfish and the tiny soft plastic crappie tubes that could reasonably resemble anything from fish to insect.

I make my casts short with the aim to target certain specific points of structure. A rocky drop off, the dead reed beds along the shallow water lines, the converging points of still and windblown waters.

A tentative, slow twitching approach. With the Rapalas and similar hard baits I incorporate long pauses into the retrieve, the jigs and spoons I countdown sink. Working them just over the bottom and crawling them up the incline of the kettle hole and into the shallows.


Fish On

The first taker; a short largemouth, waiting in a grassy ambush just before the bank. It’s a first sign of life and a good sign on what is otherwise a blustery and cool December 10th afternoon.

The pickerel too, proved active and attacked in their stealthy way.

Waking through the shallows before striking at my feet, these toothy slime darts hold a bad reputation among the more dedicated largemouth anglers, but they are a welcome sight for me. Pickerel provide fast and reliable action throughout the cold months here on Cape.

The trout proved more elusive and targeting them forces me to move to deeper and clearer waters. Rising fish are a good sign, though on this windblown pond the faint ripples of the trout are hard to discern in the light chop.

Eventually I key in on a small body of fish, holding just past the dropoff.

An Al’s goldfish, dropped for a five count and then twitched mid column draws the first strike. A glassy silver rainbow, wet hands and a quick release ensures the good health of the fish in these cold months.

With the first sparse bands of rain rolling through I make a handful of follow up casts, with occasional bumps and taps from curious fish. Finally I receive another solid strike and land one more fish.


In Conclusion

The soft light of late autumn is fading before me as the sky grays over and an early night sets in. The bare branches drip and creak and the steep banks loom behind in a peaceful shadow.

These trips are breaths of life in an otherwise dead season. They provide me with moments of reflection and a quiet, restful solace. A last cast and a last fish before the end.

All that is gold does not glitter,
Not all those who wander are lost;
The old that is strong does not wither,
Deep roots are not reached by the frost

About the author 

Calvin Toran-Sandlin

Calvin is a passionate surfcaster who grew up in the town of Falmouth here on Cape Cod. Calvin joined My Fishing Cape Cod as a member back in April of 2020, and he quickly became one of the top posters inside our forum.


  • Congrats on your outing Calvin. I’m considering picking up freshwater fishing in New England; last time I did that was when I was a kid. Thanks for the great article. Regards, Walter

  • {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

    You may also like

    Welcome to our final 2024 Members Only My Fishing Cape Cod Podcast presented by Cape & Islands Mitsubishi! In this episode, we

    Read More
    October 23rd Cape Cod Bay Report with Sam Mullen of the Goose Hummock

    Welcome to a weekend edition of the My Fishing Cape Cod Podcast presented by Cape & Islands Mitsubishi! In this podcast we

    Read More
    June 22nd South Side Fishing Report with Amy Wrightson of Sports Port
    >